Fishing Coolers – Review of the Best Choices

Fishing coolers reviewWhether you are going on a full day trip in the Florida keys for bonefish or mahi, or just a float trip for various trout species—you surely need a good fishing cooler to keep your beverages ice cold. Some coolers are much better than others, so below we have outlined the best of the best for your consideration. The worst feeling I can think of is to reach into a cooler on a hot day to grab a soda or beer, only to find out that your cooler has become warm. Marine coolers are made to be more hardcore than your average everyday family coolers. These are tough as nails and can hold ice for multiple days in a row. Not only are these awesome coolers perfect for keeping your beverages and food ice cold, they are great for keeping salmon and saltwater catches fresh on those offshore fishing trips.

In most cases, fishing coolers are not just to keep your fish and beverages cold, they are also used as seats. They will often be banged around much more than standard coolers because they’ll typically be riding in boats (on the water and on the trailer). We have displayed below some of the toughest fishing and marine coolers known to mankind, because basically—fisherman are hard on things. Find out what cooler will fit your needs the best, in our extreme list of coolers designed just for people who are extra hard on gear. Keep your beverages icy cold for up to a week with these great fishing coolers below!

Keep ice for days wih these great fishing coolers

If you want the inside of your cooler to look just like this after days of fishing, choose one of these amazing ice keeping coolers below. The coolers listed can keep ice for up to 10 days!

Pelican ProGear Elite Marine Deluxe Cooler

35 quart Pelican elite marine cooler
Price: $199.99-$359.99 (depending on the size and capacity)

Capacity: 3 sizes of this cooler are available. 35 Quart, 45 Quart and 65 Quart

Ice Holding time: 7-10 days! Yes that is correct, this fishing cooler will keep ice for up to 10 days straight.

Special features and summary:

This amazingly durable cooler is available in white and tan colors. It has 2 inch thick insulation and is crafted from the finest materials. This company has a long reputation for quality products. If you are searching for the best fishing cooler available, you have definitely found it.

  • The pelican elite fishing cooler has multiple tie down points for securing in a whitewater raft or to strap down as a seat in the front of your drift boat.
  • Freezer grade gaskets for years of cooling
  • Large hinged handles to easily move the cooler around fully loaded
  • Measuring tape molded into the top
  • Threaded hose adapter to drain out water easily
  • Certified bear resistant



Yeti Tundra 45 Quart Cooler

Yeti tundra 45 - One of the best marine coolers available.

The yeti tundra is a great marine cooler and will hold everything you need. It also holds ice for multiple days straight.

Price:  Around $400.00 for the 45 Quart. Several other sizes available

Capacity: 35-420 Quart available!

Ice Holding time: 4-5 days

Special features and summary:
The Yeti tundra is certainly a great cooler. It features 3 inches of insulation in the lid and 2 inches on the sides. It is certified as a bear resistant food container when 2 padlocks are attached to the front corners. These fishing coolers are tough as nails and will not let you down. My only gripe with yeti coolers is the rubber straps that keep them closed. They can sometimes be a pain to use, but they work well.

      • Yeti Tundra fishing coolers come with a nice rack for keeping sandwiches and other items dry and out of the ice.
      • Freezer grade gaskets
      • Optional tie down kit and many other accessories available
      • Non slip rubber feet to keep the cooler stable
      • 5 year guarantee


Coleman 70-Quart Xtreme Marine Cooler
The Coleman Xtreme cooler will hold ice for a few days easily.

Price: $52-$99

Capacity: 70 Quart

Ice Holding time: 2-4 days on average

Special features and summary:

Coleman Xtreme marine fishing cooler is not as high quality as the options above, but for a fraction of the cost of the Yeti and Pelican, it can be considered a good cooler for the price.

      • Tight closing lid
      • Holds ice well for the price
      • Cup holders built into the lid
      • A pretty light #17 weight
      • Holds up to 96 cans

Updated 12-21-15 to include this stud of a cooler

 Igloo Super Tough STX Cooler

Igloo STX fishing style cooler mounted in a drift boat

My friend has this Igloo STX super tough cooler mounted in his drift boat as a seat. As you can see he also opted for the optional foam pad for comfortable sitting while fishing.

This Igloo STX definately fits in the best fishing cooler category. My friend has used this very cooler (in the picture above) for 3 trout fishing guiding seasons on the Snake river. His guest that rides in the front of the boat sits right on the cooler while navigating the river. The foam pad on the top is an optional accessory. This cooler comes with beefed up heavy duty hinges for long lasting durability. Everything about these coolers are tough, because if they weren’t, my co-worker would not still be using this cooler after 3 years. In the summer months fishing guides are going in and out of coolers non stop, if the hinges aren’t strong – they’ll fail (especially with people sitting on them). This versatile cooler is made with the fisherman in mind and it holds ice very well. It comes with a 3 year warranty from the manufacturer, but chances are – you won’t have to worry about this cooler failing.

Price: $79.00-$149.00

Capacity: 54 or 72 quart

Ice Holding Time: Cooler stores ice up to 5 days at 90°F

Updated 03-24-2016 to Add this line of great marine coolers

Orca Coolers

Orca 40 quart marine cooler in green. These grat coolers are made in the US.

This is a 40 quart Orca cooler. One major benefit of this brand is that they are made in the US. Check out this Orca on Amazon here.

There is a large price range of these coolers, because they are offered in such a wide range of sizes. Check out the latest Amazon prices here.

Orca is a recently created marine cooler company. The beauty of this company is that all of their coolers are made here in the US. Upon looking at Orca coolers, you’ll quickly notice the similarities to Yeti coolers. Orca coolers are bear proof (just like the Yeti’s) and will hold ice just as good as the Yeti brand. Orca is a growing company and I for one, really like their great lineup of coolers. This company also has a nice array of available accessories for these coolers, some examples include pads for the top and even wheels for easy rolling around. You can also get your cooler custom silk screened!

Features of the Orca Brand Coolers

  • Made in USA
  • Various Size Options: 20 qt, 26 qt, 40 qt, 58 qt, 75 qt, 140 qt.
  • Lifetime Warranty
  • Holds ice for up to 10 days

Watch here to see a 700 lb grizzly go to town on an Orca. This bear gives this cooler a good workout, but it still doesn’t ever gain access to whats inside. The odds of your cooler ever coming into contact with a grizzly are fairly slim (unless you live in my area) But still, this video does a good job of showing the durability of this lne of American made coolers.


As you can see there are a lot of great cooler options and a wide range in price. These are just a few examples that I am familiar with. In my opinion, the best fishing cooler overall is the Pelican elite. All of these great coolers have strong points, and they will all do a great job of keeping your beer and pop cold on those fishing trips. You can determine which cooler is best for you by evaluating the features above and making a sound decision.

If you aren’t looking to break the bank the Igloo STX is among the best fishing ice chests on the market for the money.  If you are looking for the best and toughest coolers you can buy, the Pelican, Yeti and Orca coolers are a good way to go. If you are not interested in spending a small fortune and you just want the best fishing cooler for under $100, take a closer look at the Coleman marine extreme cooler.

Watch this Recent Troutster Video!

Pin It

Related Stuff


  1. Werner

    October 4, 2014 at 5:10 pm

    I bought a yeti last year and it is about as good of purchase as I have ever made. You have to use it a lot to get your monies worth, but since I am hunting and fishing 3 times a week I certainly get the use out of mine. My buddy just bought an Igloo STX and he loves it, costs about 100$ can be seen here Seems like a nice cooler for the money..

    • Dub Paetz

      October 4, 2014 at 10:20 pm

      That does look like a nice cooler! My friend uses one in his drift boat as the front seat, they even make pads for them. I’ll ask him about it and perhaps add it to this list. Thanks for the comment

Leave a Reply

Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Subscribe For Latest Updates

Signup for our newsletter and get notified when we publish new articles for free!